Is Hudson River Crash 'Good' News? Not Everyone Agrees

I wanted to preserve the poll results from last week asking ou viewers whether they thought the Hudson River plane crash was good news and belonged here, or not. The results might make you wonder...

I would welcome a Hudson River rescue story/video on the site... 72%

I'd rather not see the story about surviving a plane crash... 15%

Not sure... 13%

But, it doesn't surprise me. I am used to this, after 11 years. It is a very narrow range of story that EVERYONE can agree is "good news"

Were you surprised by these numbers? 

Comments (9)

Subscribe to this comment's feed

Ziji said:

How is "Cool-headed, Experienced Pilot Saves Entire Crew and All Passengers" NOT good news??? Are the 15% just people who are afraid of flying? What were their reasons???

January 23, 2009

oceana55 said:

I thought it was wonderful news. I guess it depends on if you are seeing "crash" or seeing, "no one was killed" This is probably the first time there has been a major air crash where no one was killed. What is not good about that? The only thing that didn't survive was something that wasn't alive. Hooray!!!

January 26, 2009

tonymynd said:

NOT AT ALL, LIFE IS SEEN WITH MANY DIFFERENT GLASSES, INCLUDING YOUR BELIEVES

January 28, 2009

bivvy said:

Personally I found the story heart warming. This guy's dedication to safety and skill. I respect others' beliefs though, and agree with Tony that we all view it through different lenes. I agree Geri was right to run it as the survey showed many people would otherwise miss out being warmed by it. I hope those that found it a little distressing do understand.

January 29, 2009

anneounschooler said:

We were in NYC shortly after this happened...and to be there next to the Hudson River, knowing what had happened on it, felt really POWERFUL. That pilot and that river saved countless numbers of lives. I believe that anyone involved in that landing will tell you that it's good news, and I agree!

February 05, 2009

storedhoney said:

Not only was it good news because no one died, but it was good news personally for the pilot and for the future of safe flights. Pilot Chesley Sullenberger has worked years on safety air research and training crews crisis management. The fact that every one is safe after the landing will only help with airplane safety and training. How cool is it that he personally searched the plane to make sure it was empty?

February 18, 2009

RAC92104 said:

I agree with StoredHoney and toward a possibility of some angels under those wings.

February 19, 2009

piquiquas said:

Definitely good, if not great, news! Birds fly. Airplanes fly. The fact that those birds crossed the path of the airliner is an unfortunate accident but the outcome, due to the professionalism of the entire crew, should be celebrated!

April 05, 2009

jlocke said:

There is good news from everything. I believe it is what is focused on. Would you read "Plane Crash" or "Great Landing!".

July 03, 2009